"just leave"

It has been three months since I started working as a psychologist, and if there is one thing these three months have taught me, it is how often my years of advocacy are humbled by lived experience.

You would assume that spending years reading about society, poverty and systemic inequality would prepare you for engaging with the communities who experience all of these things. After all, I have spent so much time reading, writing, discussing and advocating about these issues. But there is something very different about reading about a social phenomenon and having to navigate it in your everyday life.

There have been many moments when I questioned the systems we have in place. This is a reflection about Malaysia, particularly the social environment I have been away from for more than six years now. It reminds me so much of my experience attending school in Kelantan, where sexism, xenophobia and misogyny were so casually displayed that they almost became part of everyday life.

The only difference between me and the person I was back then is that I now have the vocabulary to describe what I am witnessing.

When I was in the UK and Banting, I learnt all the terms, the theories and the frameworks. I learnt about patriarchy, institutional discrimination, social conditioning, power structures and how inequality is reproduced across generations. I could identify these things in the books I read and the conversations I had. Now, I find myself encountering them in real life, and suddenly, all those words carry a much heavier meaning.

At first, I was angry. Sangat marah, actually. At the number of sexist remarks, the jokes people made about my relationship status, and men old enough to be my father feeling comfortable flirting with me. There were moments when I genuinely wondered how people could say certain things so casually, without even considering how uncomfortable they might make someone else feel.

And I still don't think I should have to dismiss my own experiences. I have every right to establish boundaries, to feel uncomfortable and to expect people to treat me with respect.

But over time, I found myself thinking about something else. Can we really expect someone to recognise sexism when their entire lives, sexist jokes have simply been jokes? When the people around them have been making the same remarks for decades, when the women in their lives have learnt to tolerate these behaviours, and when nobody has ever really challenged them?

How do you begin to explain something that someone has never been taught to question?

I think this is where my understanding of social inequality has become a little more complicated. We come from very different backgrounds. Our access to education, exposure to different communities, socioeconomic circumstances and lived experiences shape how we understand the world. Some of us have had the privilege of entering spaces where these conversations are encouraged. Others have spent their entire lives in environments where these discussions are almost unheard of.

And sometimes, I have to remind myself that I am looking at these experiences through the lens of someone who has had the opportunity to leave, to study elsewhere, to meet different people and to learn a language that allows me to articulate things that I once struggled to understand myself.

There is a certain privilege in that. I spent more than six years outside Malaysia. Six years of meeting people who challenged my beliefs, accessing literature that introduced me to perspectives I had never considered, participating in advocacy movements and building friendships with people whose lives were very different from mine. I had the opportunity to question the environment I grew up in because I was given the opportunity to experience something else.

But what about the people who never had that opportunity? How do we expect someone to question the very environment that has shaped their understanding of what is normal? How much of our worldview is determined by the circumstances we are born into, the people we meet and the opportunities available to us?

Sometimes, I wonder whether my frustration comes from expecting people to arrive at conclusions that took me years, and a considerable amount of privilege, to arrive at myself.

There is also something quite strange about returning to a place you once called home and realising that you no longer relate to certain parts of it. I recognise the humour, the conversations, the social expectations and even the ways people interact with one another. I grew up here. I understand the cultural nuances. Yet, I find myself questioning things that I probably wouldn't have questioned ten years ago.

It is almost like becoming a stranger to the environment that shaped you. Perhaps this is what happens when you spend years outside the social circles you grew up in. You develop a different set of expectations, become exposed to different ways of living and gradually realise that things you once accepted as normal are things you no longer want to tolerate. I sometimes wonder whether this is reverse culture shock, or whether I am simply growing into someone whose values have changed considerably.

For years, I was involved in advocacy, particularly with marginalised and minority communities in the UK. I worked with people whose experiences often reflected the issues I was reading about. There was a structure I could follow, and I could see the connections between the books I read, the theories I learnt and the communities I worked with. I understood the context in which I was doing my advocacy, even when the work itself was difficult.

Malaysia has been different.

Coming back has meant confronting the very things I thought I had already understood. It is one thing to discuss patriarchy in a feminist reading group, to write about xenophobia on social media, or to talk about systemic inequality in an academic setting. It is another to sit in a room, listen to people speak, observe how they interact with one another and realise that some of the things you have spent years challenging are deeply embedded in their everyday lives. And I think there is something quite humbling about that. I am beginning to understand just how much I still have to learn about the society I come from.

I have also found myself asking: kenapa kita masih mahu berada dalam persekitaran yang menyakitkan kita?

My first instinct has always been to leave. To go somewhere I don't have to constantly explain myself, defend my boundaries or deal with the exhaustion of navigating everyday sexism. In the UK, I rarely had to confront certain things in quite the same way. But then I remind myself that the environment I experienced there was shaped by generations of activists, organisers and ordinary people who fought for the rights and protections that many of us now benefit from.

Those rights did not just appear. Someone had to do the work. Someone had to challenge the jokes, question the institutions, organise communities, write about uncomfortable things and keep having conversations even when nobody wanted to listen.

And I find myself questioning my own commitment to advocacy. I talk so much about resistance, about fighting for a better society, about the importance of solidarity. Kalau setiap kali berhadapan dengan sesuatu yang tidak selari dengan prinsip saya, perkara pertama yang terlintas di fikiran ialah untuk meninggalkan tempat tersebut, bagaimana pula dengan masyarakat yang saya tinggalkan?

I know this is a complicated question. Nobody should be expected to stay in an environment where they experience harassment or abuse. I don't think women should have to sacrifice their safety just to prove their commitment to social change. There are times when leaving is necessary, and there should never be any shame in choosing yourself.

But I also think about the communities I want to contribute to. If I genuinely believe that things can be better, surely I have to be willing to understand the people and environments where these changes need to happen.

This also brings me to something I have been struggling with: empathy.

We talk about empathy so frequently, particularly in psychology, but I am beginning to realise how difficult it can be to practise when you are personally affected by someone's behaviour. It is easy to talk about social conditioning when discussing an issue in theory. It becomes considerably harder when you are the person at the receiving end of a sexist remark.

I find myself moving between wanting to challenge someone and wanting to understand where that behaviour comes from. Can I understand someone's upbringing and circumstances while still holding them accountable for their actions? Can I acknowledge that someone might have had limited exposure to conversations about gender equality without excusing the things they say and do?

And perhaps an even more uncomfortable question: are we only willing to extend empathy to people whose values already align with ours? I think advocacy spaces can sometimes become echo chambers. We become comfortable discussing oppression with people who already understand it. We know the terminology, agree on certain principles and have a shared understanding of the problems we want to address. But what happens when we encounter people who don't share these understandings? What happens when the conversation becomes uncomfortable, when someone disagrees with us, or when we realise that the person we are speaking to has an entirely different understanding of the world?

I am still learning how to navigate these conversations. At the same time, I am beginning to question how much emphasis we place on changing individual attitudes when the structures around us remain largely untouched.

A person might personally disagree with sexism but continue participating in an organisational culture that normalises it. Someone might recognise the importance of mental health but work in an environment where seeking psychological support is stigmatised. People might want better work-life balance but have very little control over their working conditions. Someone might understand the importance of establishing boundaries but live in a culture where hierarchy makes it difficult to do so.

How much can we realistically expect from individuals when the structures around them continue to reinforce the very behaviours we are asking them to change? We can conduct as many awareness programmes as we want, tell people to be more empathetic, encourage healthier communication and educate them about gender equality. But what happens when they return to environments that continue to reward the opposite?

This is something I find particularly interesting now that I am working in psychology. We spend so much time looking at individual behaviour, attitudes and coping mechanisms, but people's experiences are shaped by much larger social and institutional structures. I think it would be a disservice to the communities we work with if we expected them to solve problems that are also produced by the environments they live and work in.

And perhaps I am also learning to let go of certain romanticised ideas about the communities I engage with.

We sometimes speak about marginalisation as though people who experience oppression will automatically recognise it in others. But people are complicated. Someone can experience discrimination because of their socioeconomic background and still make sexist remarks. Someone can be marginalised in one aspect of their life and hold considerable prejudice towards another community. Someone can understand what it feels like to be excluded and still participate in excluding others.

These contradictions are uncomfortable, especially when they challenge the narratives we have grown accustomed to in advocacy spaces. I think I have to be careful about how I understand solidarity too. We cannot assume that people who experience one form of inequality will automatically recognise another. The experiences of marginalisation do not necessarily make someone more progressive, and having experienced hardship does not automatically mean someone has developed empathy towards everyone else.

Sometimes, I catch myself thinking that certain attitudes are backwards, terkebelakang, or simply difficult to comprehend. But what does that actually achieve? How much do I really understand about someone's circumstances if I have already decided that they are incapable of understanding mine?

I don't want to become someone who speaks about marginalised communities with so much conviction but struggles to engage with people whose experiences and worldviews are different from mine. I don't want my education to become a reason for me to look down on people. And I certainly don't want to mistake knowing the right terminology for having a complete understanding of the people behind those experiences.

Of course, there is also a certain loneliness that comes with this. Sometimes, it can be quite exhausting to constantly find yourself questioning things that everyone else seems perfectly comfortable with. There are conversations where I wonder whether I should say something, whether it is worth explaining myself, or whether I should simply let it pass. I miss having spaces where these discussions happen naturally, where I don't have to explain why certain things matter to me.

I miss the familiarity of being surrounded by people who understand the things I care about. I miss being able to discuss feminism, social inequality and politics without having to first establish why these conversations are important.

And this brings me to something I have been thinking about quite a lot lately.

I spent many weekends away from work attending events with like-minded people. People who understand my occasional remarks about sexism, patriarchy and gender inequality, sometimes even when I have barely finished saying a sentence. There is a certain comfort in being around people who understand you without requiring an explanation. You can make a passing remark, reference something you have read, or express frustration about a particular social issue, and someone will immediately know what you are talking about.

You feel seen. You feel understood. And honestly, after spending most of your week navigating environments where these conversations might not come so naturally, that comfort is something I deeply appreciate. But I have also started wondering whether I have become too comfortable with these spaces.

If I spend my weekends surrounded by people who already share my values, who understand the language of feminism and recognise the same social injustices that I do, am I really challenging my own understanding of society? Or am I simply reinforcing what I already believe? I worry about becoming so accustomed to being understood that I eventually lose the willingness to engage with people who don't share my worldview.

I can keep returning to spaces where everyone understands my occasional remarks about patriarchy. I can attend another discussion, another book club, another advocacy event, and leave feeling reassured that there are people who see the world in much the same way I do. But if I never step outside those circles, the people I meet during my weekends might eventually become an echo chamber.

And perhaps the harder work is elsewhere.

It is in engaging with people who might never have considered these issues, having conversations that don't always go as expected, and learning how to communicate ideas that I have spent years discussing in much more familiar environments.

It is much easier to talk about patriarchy with someone who already recognises it than to explain why a particular sexist joke might be harmful to someone who genuinely thinks it is funny. It is much easier to discuss inequality with people who already understand structural disadvantages than to begin that conversation with someone who has never thought about these things in that way.

But if I keep choosing the spaces where I am most understood, when do I actually do the harder work?

For years, advocacy has been a huge part of my life. There is something exciting about organising an event, facilitating a discussion, publishing an article or seeing people engage with something you have created. You get to see the immediate outcome of your efforts, and sometimes, you receive the reassurance that the work you are doing matters.

But working within a community is a different experience. Sometimes, the work is repetitive conversations, small interventions, explaining the same things over and over again, navigating bureaucracy and accepting that you might not see the impact of your efforts. Sometimes, you might spend an entire day trying to get a programme approved, only to realise that the actual work has barely begun.

And sometimes, you simply have to show up again the next day.

I think I am beginning to understand that meaningful social change can be incredibly mundane. It does not always look like a protest, a campaign, a viral post or a room full of people agreeing with one another. Sometimes, it is having a difficult conversation with one person. Sometimes, it is creating a space where someone feels comfortable asking for help. Sometimes, it is introducing an idea that someone might only begin to understand months or years later.

There is a lot of work that happens outside the things we celebrate as activism, and perhaps I need to become more comfortable with that.

Have I done enough in the past three months? Entahlah. I don't think anyone can answer that question for me, including myself.

I know that I have a lot more to learn about the people I work with and the society I live in. I know that my years of studying psychology and doing advocacy have given me certain perspectives, but these perspectives will continue to be challenged as I meet more people and experience more of the world outside the spaces I have occupied.

I don't know if I will ever become entirely comfortable with some of the things I encounter. I hope I don't. I hope I never become so accustomed to certain behaviours that I stop questioning them. But I also hope I learn to approach people with enough curiosity to understand where they come from, and enough conviction to challenge what needs challenging.

Three months in. Banyak lagi yang perlu dipelajari, banyak lagi kerja yang perlu dibuat.

Comments